Adventists for Tomorrow

Our mission is to provide a free and open medium that will assist individuals in forming accurate, balanced, and thoughtful opinions regarding issues within and without the church.

You are not logged in.

Announcement

Due to a large increase in spam, I have frozen forum registration. If you are new to the site and want to register, e-mail me personally at vandolson@gmail.com. Thank you.

#1 01-25-10 4:29 pm

bob_2
Member
Registered: 12-28-08
Posts: 3,790

Egalitarianism - Is it Utopia or practically possible

Egalitarianism:

1 : a belief in human equality especially with respect to social, political, and economic affairs
2 : a social philosophy advocating the removal of inequalities among people

Is Capitalism or Socialism better at accomplishing this? Is it a good goal?? What does the Bible teach??

Offline

#2 01-25-10 4:58 pm

bob
Member
Registered: 12-28-08
Posts: 296

Re: Egalitarianism - Is it Utopia or practically possible

True Christianity is the only answer.  Without the Holy Spirit we will never acquire equal regard for others.  The poor hate the rich and the rich look down on the poor.  The in between classes have their unique problems.

Offline

#3 01-26-10 5:37 am

jag
Member
Registered: 10-01-09
Posts: 89

Re: Egalitarianism - Is it Utopia or practically possible

Capitalism certainly does not remove inequalities between people. Quite the opposite. It's only a slightly reformed version of the Roman oppresive system that sentenced Jesus to death.

Offline

#4 01-26-10 12:25 pm

bob_2
Member
Registered: 12-28-08
Posts: 3,790

Re: Egalitarianism - Is it Utopia or practically possible

Jesus certainly wasn't against the free markets. Yes he drove the money changers out of the temple, not because he was again commerce but where they were doing it. Some of Christ's parable talk of rich men, giving subordinates money to invest for them. That doesn't sound like socialism, more like capitalism.

Offline

#5 01-26-10 8:00 pm

don
Member
Registered: 12-28-08
Posts: 1,121

Re: Egalitarianism - Is it Utopia or practically possible

Social Medicine

Keep baby Isaiah on supports? Parents want 90 days to assess. Hospital says 30. Alberta Judge to rule. http://preview.tinyurl.com/y8vow8p

The ethical dilemma here even touches on the Capitalism/Socialism discussion.  They say the Judge is to decide tomorrow, Wednesday, January 27.

Offline

#6 01-26-10 11:00 pm

jag
Member
Registered: 10-01-09
Posts: 89

Re: Egalitarianism - Is it Utopia or practically possible

bob_2, the parables of Jesus were... parables! They were not meant to endorse or criticise an economic system but to illustrate a point. If you mean that Jesus was not against free fruit and veg markets in villages, then you are probably right - this was how people made a living. But it would be distorting to say that by analogy Jesus would support the kind of free market economy that we know today. And to claim that we would endorse ridiculosly high CEO salaries would be simply a lie. After all, modern socialism wasn't invented back then (and even now it hasn't really been tested anywhere), but the way his Jerusalem followers lived (as depicted in Acts) suggests pure communism.

Don, what you mentioned is certainly an ethical dilemma, but exactly the same dilemma will exist whether we live in socialist or capitalist surroundings.

Offline

#7 01-27-10 2:42 am

bob_2
Member
Registered: 12-28-08
Posts: 3,790

Re: Egalitarianism - Is it Utopia or practically possible

Jesus interacted with the rich young ruler, but he loved his money more than his Saviour. I think Jesus today would give the same test, don't you?

Offline

Board footer

Powered by FluxBB